The world has changed. The illusion of a global rules-based order, in which the powerful respected international law and the weak could rely on it for protection, is dissolving fast. Even the architects of that order increasingly concede what small nations long suspected: the rules were never applied equally.
When economic coercion, military power and geopolitical rivalry shape international behaviour, small nations cannot wait for the old order to protect them. For the Pasifika, this is not a moment for despair. It is a moment that demands visionary leadership.
For decades, the Pacific Islands Forum has been our collective voice. Its 2050 Strategy for the Blue Pacific Continent shows we can think beyond electoral cycles. The Parties to the Nauru Agreement have shown that bargaining together over tuna secures genuine economic returns. Pasifika diplomacy has helped bring climate obligations before the International Court of Justice. These are considerable achievements.
But a harder question confronts our leaders: is a Forum designed for consultation and consensus equipped for an increasingly contested geopolitical environment?
Antalya: A Lesson in Collective Strength
At COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, Pasifika nations have again shown what collective diplomacy can achieve. Under the Belau Declaration, Forum leaders are demanding stronger emissions reductions, accessible climate finance and greater protection for our oceans. They continue to defend the 1.5°C goal, because for our islands climate change is no abstract debate. It threatens our land, livelihoods, cultures and sovereignty.
Yet the Pasifika-owned Pacific Resilience Facility remains more than US$300 million short of its funding target.
The clearest message from Antalya came from our Permanent Secretary for Environment and Climate Change, Dr Sivendra Michael, at the Moana Blue Pacific Pavilion: “Do not push your solutions on us. Let us design our own solutions.”
He speaks from experience. Fiji has safely relocated six communities from red zones, with two more under way. Dr Michael stressed that relocation must remain a last resort, because it is about far more than moving people. It means protecting ancestral ties to land and ocean, cultural heritage, human rights and dignity, with communities at the centre of every decision.
His financing message was equally direct. The Pasifika has “proven concepts, proven solutions”, and is asking for direct budget access through national systems. Funding must be context-specific, not approaches that work elsewhere but suit small islands poorly.
Antalya also exposes a deeper challenge. Australia, a major regional partner and Forum member, is co-leading the COP31 negotiations with Türkiye, yet its continuing fossil-fuel expansion raises legitimate questions about the consistency of its climate leadership. This is not an argument against Australia. It is a reminder that even our closest partners have national interests that do not always coincide with ours.
The Pasifika must therefore develop the capacity to negotiate independently, including with those who provide much of the Forum’s financial support. Our collective voice must never depend on the generosity, preferences or strategic calculations of others.
And climate change is only one frontier.
The Ocean as Geopolitical Battleground
Consider the growing contest over our seabed. China is expanding its deep-ocean research capabilities. The United States is advancing strategic infrastructure and critical-minerals interests. Others are pursuing ports, undersea cables and fisheries.
The Cook Islands’ seabed resources illustrate the dilemma. Should each government negotiate separately with powerful countries and multinational corporations, each offering different incentives, technologies and security assurances? Or should the Pasifika develop common negotiating principles that protect our collective interests?
The PNA offers a precedent. By coordinating fishing access, its members strengthened their position against far larger commercial interests. Why should similar principles not guide negotiations over deep-sea mining, digital infrastructure, strategic ports and maritime security?
The answer requires political courage. Individual sovereignty is precious. But sovereignty exercised without collective leverage can become vulnerability disguised as independence.
When Consensus Becomes Paralysis
The Pacific Way, grounded in consultation, respect and communal harmony, is among our greatest strengths. It should not be discarded. But consensus must remain a means of achieving collective purpose, not an instrument for frustrating it.
The Forum’s handling of China’s ballistic missile test exposed this vulnerability. Leaders eventually registered concern and called for greater transparency and advance notification, but disagreement among members prevented a fully unanimous position.
Should one or two members be able to stop the rest from voicing a common position on regional security?
A reformed Forum could keep consensus as its preferred approach while allowing clearly defined decisions by a substantial majority, particularly on urgent security and strategic matters. Members choosing not to participate could formally record their reservations without blocking others. Such arrangements would need carefully negotiated safeguards, including respect for national sovereignty and transparent decision-making.
The aim is not a Pasifika super-government. It is to stop collective weakness from becoming the price of preserving individual independence.
Three Strategic Changes
First, the Forum must move from passive diplomacy towards active collective bargaining. Pasifika countries should establish common negotiating frameworks for deep-sea mining, strategic infrastructure, digital connectivity, maritime access and external security arrangements. Governments would keep final authority over sovereign decisions, but would negotiate from a shared understanding of regional interests, environmental safeguards and acceptable conditions. External powers should no longer assume that competing offers can divide the Pasifika into separate negotiating markets.
Second, we need a genuinely Pasifika-led security architecture. Our Ocean of Peace aspirations must be backed by practical mechanisms for consultation, early warning, maritime surveillance, disaster response and coordinated diplomacy. This architecture must be shaped by island priorities, not become an extension of any external power’s strategy. Australia and New Zealand remain indispensable partners, but partnership must not be confused with ownership of the regional agenda.
Third, the Forum needs stronger institutional capacity. A visionary declaration means little without the machinery to implement it. The Secretariat needs stronger capabilities in strategic research, economic negotiation, legal analysis and geopolitical assessment. The Forum should also publish measurable progress against its 2050 Strategy, so citizens can judge whether leaders are delivering rather than merely declaring.
Fiji’s Opportunity and Responsibility
Fiji has an important role in this transformation. Prime Minister Sitiveni Rabuka has cultivated relationships with leaders in Australia, New Zealand, China, India and other major partners. Fiji also brings practical credibility, from relocating threatened communities with dignity to insisting that climate finance reach those who need it.
But Fiji’s contribution should not be measured by how closely it aligns with any particular power. It should be measured by how effectively it strengthens the independence and collective influence of the Pasifika.
Mr Rabuka should use these relationships to advocate a more capable, adequately resourced and genuinely Pasifika-led Forum. He should tell Australia and New Zealand that a stronger Forum would be a more credible partner, not a less cooperative one, and deliver the same message to China, India, the United States, Japan and the European Union.
Fiji must also practise what it advocates: consulting its neighbours before entering arrangements with wider regional implications, and ensuring that national partnerships reinforce rather than undermine collective interests.
Where Are Our Visionary Leaders?
Institutional reform is only part of the challenge. The greater question is leadership.
Do our leaders see beyond their next election, their next development grant, their next bilateral agreement? The 2050 Strategy demands exactly that.
Our grandchildren will inherit the consequences of today’s decisions over seabed resources, climate finance, military access, digital infrastructure and economic dependence. They will not ask how many communiqués we issued or how many conferences our leaders attended. They will ask whether we protected their ocean, preserved their sovereignty and secured their future.
The great powers have shown their capacity to wield economic and military might. Our response cannot be to appeal to rules those same powers selectively observe. Nor should it be to choose one powerful patron over another. It must be to build collective Pasifika power on our own terms.
The Blue Pacific is not an empty strategic space awaiting occupation or exploitation. It is our ancestral home, our economic inheritance and our children’s future.
The ocean is rising. Geopolitical competition is intensifying. The old order is changing. The question is whether our leaders have the vision and courage to change with it.